A clear chain
from claim to conclusion.
Each evaluation starts with a specific claim. The question is whether the methods and measurements support that claim, within the conditions actually studied.
The claim
Identify the exact assertion, its source, the product version, and the intended use. Distinguish composition, measurement, detection, prediction, and performance claims.
The science
Examine the proposed scientific basis and the evidence cited. Identify the phenomenon of interest, what is directly measured, and any assumptions connecting the measurement to the claim.
The test
Examine the protocol, comparator, sample, repeatability, and relevant sources of variation. State whether the evaluation involves original laboratory testing, a reanalysis, or a review of published evidence.
The conclusion
Explain what the findings support and what remains unresolved. Keep conclusions specific to the evaluated claim, population, product version, and testing conditions.
The evidence file
Present the source claim, methods, results, references, limitations, and relevant disclosures. Record publication dates and substantive revisions so readers can follow the reasoning.
What is measured?
What is inferred?
A precise measurement does not, by itself, establish that the interpretation attached to it is valid. Each step needs its own supporting evidence.
Analytical performance, reproducibility, and relevance to the advertised outcome are evaluated as separate questions.